What you should know or how you should conduct yourself before engaging in debate.
Chris Naum’s latest ‘Taking It To The Streets’ program on FirefighterNetcast is “Victim Survivability Profiling” with guest FDNY Captain Stephen Marsar (Division 3). This topic is probably the most heated debate within the fire service, possibly topping searching vacant buildings.
I am familiar with the debate going around on this tactic. It was also an interesting subject at FDIC this year. Whether or not you agree with Captain Marsar’s research, I’d like to point out a few things that would help everyone when you discuss it.
First, read the research paper.
Much of what is being discussed is based on hearsay and emotion. If you’re going to take a stand, make sure it’s on a solid foundation.
Finally, treat the other guy with respect.
Sure, we’re not going to agree on everything. There are members on the same department in some places that can’t agree on strategy and tactics.
No one is going to win any arguments when we start throwing around “sallies” and “cowboys”
Captain Marsar’s research “Can They Be Saved? Utilizing Civilian Survivability Profiling to Enhance Size-Up and Reduce Firefighter Fatalities in the Fire Department, City of New York” recently won a U.S. Fire Administration’s Outstanding Research Award as part of the Executive Fire Officer program.
Read the paper, listen to the broadcast and then, most importantly, see what truly applies to you.
There’s a lot to consider when trying to make the stairs.
Is reasoning that an occupant is dead or alive one of them?
We encourage and support constructive dialogue and debate. View our comment policy.
Also on Backstep Firefighter …
- Protecting Lives – February 8, 2013
- Does This Label Look Familiar? – December 6, 2013
- A Profiling Scenario
Do you know what your next move is? – August 13, 2012
- So What Are We Supposed to Do? – August 3, 2012